1957/58 -- 1st Season

1. Teahouse of the August Moon, January, Arthur Sircom
2. Gaslight, April, Noel Hume

 

1958/59 -- 2nd Season

• Ruddigore, September, (not cast)

3. Waltz of the Toreadors, February, Barry Wilson

 

1959/60 -- 3rd Season

4. You Can't Take It With You, November, Carn Andrews
5. All My Sons, February, Barry Wilson
6. The Mousetrap, April, Edith Carrington

 

1960/61 -- 4th Season

7. East Lynne, September, Wassie Hamilton
8. Beauty and the Beast, December, Janet Wunshell
9. Sabrina Fair, February, Edith Carrington
10. My Three Angels, May, Wassie Hamilton

 

1961/62 -- 5th Season

11. The Drunkard, October, Wassie Hamilton
12. The Giaconda Smile, April, Carl Balsan
13. The Girls in 509, May, Carl Balsan

 

1962/63 -- 6th Season

14. Streets of New York, October, Wassie Hamilton
15. Separate Tables, April, Carl Balsan
16. Curious Savage, May, Carl Balsan

 

1963/64 -- 7th Season

17. Dracula, October, Will Keys
18. Imaginary Invalid, January, Will Keys
19. Someone Waiting, March, Alice Schriener
20. Blithe Spirit, May, Will Keys

 

1964/65 -- 8th Season

21. The Gazebo, November, Will Keys
22. Hedda Gabler, January, Will Keys
23. Breath of Spring, March, Will Keys
24. Man in the Dog Suit, May, Ray Hilton

 

1965/66 -- 9th Season

25. Tender Trap, November, Bob Jones
26. The Fantasticks, January, Howard Scammon
27. See How They Run, March, Ray Hilton
28. Elizabeth the Queen, May, Ray Hilton

 

1966/67 -- 10th Season

29. Tom Jones, September, Ray Hilton
30. A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, January, Robert Weeks
31. The Glass Menagerie, March, Lou Catron
32. Pool's Paradise, May, Ray Hilton

 

1967/68 -- 11th Season

33. Irma La Douce, September, Ray Hilton
34. Witness for the Prosecution, November, Dan Roth
35. Sunday in New York, February, Marion Brown
36. Mary of Scotland, March, Ray Hilton
37. Once Upon a Mattress, May, Dan Roth

 

1968/69 -- 12th Season

38. Stop the World, I Want to Get Off, September, Dan Roth
39. Luv, November, Dan Roth
40. Medea, January, Dan Roth
41. Catch Me If You Can, March, J. Kleeman
42. The Boy Friend, May, Nancy Cole

 

1969/70 -- 13th Season

43. Paint Your Wagon, September, Dan Roth
44. Critic's Choice, November, Gary Battaglia
45. Candida, January, Gary Battaglia
46. The Chalk Garden, March, Cindy Hitchens
47. Baby Want a Kiss, May, Richard Tirrill
48. The Boys in the Band, July, Gary Battaglia

 

1970/71 -- 14th Season

49. Your Own Thing, October, Gary Battaglia
50. Two for the Seesaw, November, Pat Blatt
51. Ladies in Retirement, February, Pat Blatt
52. The Play's the Thing, May, Pat Blatt

 

1971/72 -- 15th Season

53. Lily, the Felon's Daughter, September, Tom Miller
54. The Fourposter, November, Pat Blatt
55. Ghosts, January, Howard Scammon
56. Design for Murder, March, Wassie Hamilton
57. Mary, Mary, May, Pat Blatt

 

1972/73 -- 16th Season

58. Any Wednesday, September, Will Keys
59. Butterflies Are Free, November, Howard Scammon
60. Suddenly Last Summer, January, Sally Darling
61. Wait Until Dark, March, Pat Blatt
62. Arsenic and Old Lace, May, Sam Heatwole

 

1973/74 -- 17th Season

63. The Lady's Not For Burning, November, Sally Darling
64. You Know I Can't Hear You When the Water's Running, January, Sam Heatwole
65. You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, March, Kate Graverson
66. Delicate Balance, May, Howard Scammon
67. An Evening With Noel and Cole, July, Sally Darling

 

1974/75 -- 18th Season

68. The Last of the Red Hot Lovers, September, Sam Heatwole
69. Outward Bound, November, Howard Scammon
70. Night Must Fall, January, Harvey Credle
71. Absence of a Cello, March, Pat Blatt
72. Another Evening With Noel and Cole, May, Sally Darling

 

1975/76 -- 19th Season

73. Marriage-Go-Round, December, Kate Graverson
74. Thurber Carnival, February, Sally Darling
75. The Gypsy's Curse, April, Bennett Wilson

 

1976/77 -- 20th Season

76. A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, September, Kate Graverson
77. How the Other Half Loves, November, Pat Blatt
78. Sheep On the Runway, January, Sam Heatwole
79. Bus Stop, May, Rogers Hamilton
80. Roar of the Greasepaint, Smell of the Crowd, July, Kate Graverson

 

1977/78 -- 21st Season

81. The Importance of Being Earnest, September, Howard Scammon
82. The Glass Menagerie, November, Sally Darling
83. Barefoot in the Park, January, Sam Heatwole
84. Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, March, Rogers Hamilton
85. Celebration, May, Larry Ketron
86. 6 Rms Riv Vu, June, Jack Poland
87. Noel and Cole - Encore, August, Sally Darling

 

1978/79 -- 22nd Season

88. The Little Foxes, September, Tim Jones
89. Once Upon a Mattress, November, Harvey Credle
90. Private Lives, January, Sam Heatwole
91. Ah, Wilderness, March, Sally Darling
92. The Owl and the Pussycat, April, Curry Worsham
93. Riverwind, June, Jim Brittain
94. Same Time, Next Year, August, Sally Darling

 

1979/80 -- 23rd Season

95. Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, September, Sam Heatwole
96. Carnival, November, Harvey Credle
97. Sleuth, January, Frank Stevenson
98. You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, March, Bill Taylor
99. Blithe Spirit, April, Kent Thompson
100. By George and Ira, Summer, Sally Darling
101. Invitation to a March, Summer, Frank Stevenson

 

1980-81 -- 24th Season

102. The Mousetrap, September, Dick Overdorf
103. Christmas Fantasia, November, Dann Cunningham
104. All My Sons, January, Kent Thompson
105. Play It Again, Sam, March, Kate Graverson
106. The Voice of the Turtle, May, Jim Brittain
107. The Rose Tatoo, Summer, Sally Darling

 

1981/82 -- 25th Season

108. Chapter Two, September, Frank Stevenson
109. Pippin, November, Kate Graverson
110. On Golden Pond, January, Chris Curran
111. Wait Until Dark, March, Sam Heatwole
112. Romantic Comedy, May, John Hamant
113. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, Summer, Sally Darling

 

1982/83 -- 26th Season

114. The Skin of Our Teeth, September, Paul Sagan
115. Tintypes, November, Paul Sagan
116. The Gin Game, January, Frank Stevenson
117. Deathtrap, March, Sarah Dixon
118. Absurd Person Singular, May, Kate Graverson
119. Fallen Angels, Summer, Gemma Freeman

 

1983/84 -- 27th Season

120. Harvey, September, Terry Rouark
121. Carousel, November, Mike Sullivan
122. Ladyhouse Blues, January, Pat Blatt
123. The Real Inspector Hound, March, Sarah Dixon
124. Lunch Hour, May, Jane Underhill
125. Two for the Seesaw, Summer, Paul Sagan

 

1984/85 -- 28th Season

126. 1000 Clowns, September, Terry Rouark
127. 1940's Radio Hour, November, Don Cox
128. Talley's Folly, January, Pat Blatt
129. Mass Appeal, March, Art McMaster
130. Breath of Spring, May, Kristi Everly

 

1985/86 -- 29th Season

131. Crimes of the Heart, September, Claudine Carew
132. A Day in Hollywood/A Night in the Ukraine, November, Don Cox
133. The Dining Room, January, Sarah Dixon
134. Ten Little Indians, March, Marvin Sylvest
135. Noel Coward Tonight, May, Howard Scammon
136. 'Night mother, Summer, Sally Darling

 

1986/87 -- 30th Season

137. Sea Marks, September, Dan Smith
138. Best Little Whorehouse in Texas, November, Don Cox
139. Foxfire, January, Kristi Everly
140. The Real Thing, March, Frank Stevenson
141. Painting Churches, May, Anne Morgan
142. Greater Tuna, Summer, Claudine Carew

 

1987/88 -- 31st Season

143. Coupla White Chicks Sitting Around Talking, September, Jane Underhill
144. Stop the World, I Want to Get Off, November, Don Cox
145. The Last Meeting of the Knights of the White Magnolia, January, Marvin Sylvest
146. The Private Ear/The Public Eye, March, Sarah Dixon
147. The Circle, May, Howard Scammon
148. Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, Summer, Richard Palmer

 

1988/89 -- 32nd Season

• Educating Rita, (not produced)

149. My Three Angels, November, Jane Underhill
150. Veronica's Room, January, Lori Paschall
151. Biloxi Blues, March, Sarah Dixon
152. The Kingfisher, May, Kristi Everly
153. Moon for the Misbegotten, Summer, Richard Palmer

 

1989/90 -- 33rd Season

154. Breakfast With Les and Bess, September, Lori Paschall
155. Some Enchanted Evening, November, Lynn Walker
156. The Nerd, January, Gemma Freeman
157. True West, March, Sarah Dixon
158. Murder by the Book, May, Kim Vernall

 

1990/91 -- 34th Season

159. Steel Magnolias, September, Claudine Carew
160. Bell, Book and Candle, November, Lori Paschall
161. The Cocktail Hour, January, Gemma Freeman
162. The Price, March, Abby Schumann
163. Eleemosynary, May, Bunkie Righter

 

1991/92 -- 35th Season

164. Dial M for Murder, September, Lori Paschall
165. Our Town, November, Howard Scammon
166. Social Security, January, Roman Alis
167. A Walk in the Woods, March, Abby Schumann
168. Nunsense, May, Blanton Bradley

 

1992/93 -- 36th Season

169. Agnes of God, September, Lori Paschall
170. The Lion in Winter, November, Richard Carr
171. Lend Me a Tenor, January, Hugh Hitchens
172. Other People's Money, April, Bunkie Righter
173. The Perfect Murder, June, Debbie Noonan

 

1993/94 -- 37th Season

174. The Road to Mecca, September, Scott Stith
175. Night Watch, November, Lori Paschall
176. Rumors, February, Roman Alis
177. I Never Sang for My Father, April, Bunkie Righter
178. The Fantasticks, June, Bill Suber

 

1994/95 -- 38th Season

179. Amadeus, September, Hugh Hitchens
180. Camelot, November, Bill Suber
181. Dancing at Lughnasa, February, Lori Paschall
182. Out of Order, April, Scott Stith
183. Wait Until Dark, May, Scott Rollins

 

1995/96 -- 39th Season

184. I Ought to be In Pictures, September, Oteka Ball
185. The Boys Next Door, November, Lori Paschall
186. Postmortem, January, Madoline Wallace
187. Shadowlands, March, Les Waldron
188. Later Life, May, Scott Rollins
189. A Private Public Park, June, Jack Zilliox

 

1996/97 -- 40th Season

190. Nunsense II - The Second Coming, September, Ron Milovac
191. The Sisters Rosensweig, November, Beth Fairbanks
192. The Innocents, January, Richard Carr
193. Don't Dress for Dinner, March, Scott Stith
194. Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, May, Scott Rollins

 

1997/98 -- 41st Season

195. I Hate Hamlet, September, Kim Vernall
196. Catch Me If You Can, November, Debbie Noonan
197. Jake's Women, January, Jonathan Manning
198. Two Rooms, March, Les Waldron
199. Barefoot in the Park, May, Naomi Murrow

 

1998/99 -- 42nd Season

200. Romantic Comedy, September, Mary Campbell
201. Scotland Road, November, Richard Carr
202. Red Hot and Cole, January, Beth Cheney
203. Picnic, April, Rogers Hamilton
204. The Mousetrap, May, Debbie Noonan

 

1999/00 -- 43rd Season

205. Exit the Body, September, Susan Chast
206. On Golden Pond, November, Richard Carr
207. Dames at Sea, January, Beth Cheney
208. The Cemetary Club, March, Fran Fleming
209. Black Comedy, May, Sarah Carr

• Forever Plaid, Summer, Smithfield Little Theater Cast

 

2000-01 -- 44th Season

210. Ten Little Indians, September, Lynn Schumann
211. Nuncrackers, November, Helen D'Alfonso
212. Chapter Two, January, Rogers Hamilton
213. Laura, March, Les Waldron
214. You Can't Take It With You, May, Rick Hinson

• The Brothers Menaechmus, Summer, Edward Whitace, The New Virginia Company of Comedians

 

2001-02 -- 45th Season

215. Crossing Delancy, September, Mary Campbell
216. Soup du Jour, November, Debbie Noonan
217. An American Daughter, January, Beth Cheney
218. 84, Charing Cross Road, March, Les Waldron
219. 6 Rms Riv Vu, May, Kristi Everly Spivey

• A Delicate Balance, Summer, Richard Palmer, Wedgewood Renaissance

 

2002-03 -- 46th Season

220. Picasso at the Lapin Agile, September, Victoria Racimo
221. The Rainmaker, November, Les Waldron
222. The Secret Garden, January, Sarah Carr Howlett
223. Don't Drink the Water, March, Lynn Schumann
224. Play On!, May, Kim Vernall

 

2003-04 -- 47th Season

225. The Good Doctor, September, Beth Wigley
226. The Unexpected Guest, November, Debbie Noonan
227. Cinderella, January, Traci Strom Jackson
228. The Miss Firecracker Contest, March, Kyle
229. Bus Stop, May, Les Waldron

• Same Time, Next Year, Summer, Victoria Racimo, Palomino Productions

 

2004-05 -- 48th Season

230. See How They Run, September, Lynn Schumann & Alan Noblin
231. Over the River and Through the Woods, November, Carole Meyer
232. Man of La Mancha, January, Christopher Robbins
233. Proof, March, Abigail Schumann
234. Deathtrap, May, Les Waldron

• Sylvia, Summer, Victoria Racimo, Palomino Productions

 

2005-06 -- 49th Season

235. The Foreigner, September, Lynn Schumann
236. Marvin's Room, November, Bob Burdette
237. A Chorus Line, January, Peter Natale
238. Shirley Valentine, March, Elizabeth Wiley
239. An Act of the Imagination, May, Kate Foskit

 

2006-07 -- 50th Season

240. The Teahouse of the August Moon, September, Rogers Hamilton
241. Sleuth, November, Rob Schrader
242. The Importance of Being Earnest, January, Kathleen Walden
243. Talley's Folly, March, Brandon Lyles
244. A Day in Hollywood/A Night in the Ukraine, May, Don Cox

 

2007-08 -- 51st Season

245. Baby, September, Rob Schrader
246. Moonlight and Magnolias, November, Brandon Lyles
247. George M!, January, Peter Natale
248. Communicating Doors, March, Rick Hinson
249. Driving Miss Daisy, May, Kyle

• Retreat from Moscow, Summer, Wedgewood Renaissance Productions

 

2008/09 -- 52nd Season

250. Pump Boys and Dinettes, September, Dana Margulies
251. Father of the Bride, November, Brandon Lyles
252. The Man Who Came to Dinner, January, Peter Natale
253. On the Verge, March, Les Waldron
254. Barnum, May, Rob Schrader

Note: Unnumbered shows were either not actually produced or were produced by companies other than the Williamsburg Players.