Shows marked with "*" were not part of our regular season, not produced, or were produced by outside theatre companies.

1957/1958
• 1.) Teahouse of the August Moon, January, Arthur Sircom
1958/1959
•  * ) Ruddigore, September, not cast
• 2.) Gaslight, April, Noel Hume
• 3.) Waltz of the Toreadors, February, Barry Wilson
1959/1960
• 4.) You Can't Take It With You, November, Carn Andrews
• 5.) All My Sons, February, Barry Wilson
• 6.) The Mousetrap, April, Edith Carrington
1960/1961
• 7.) East Lynne, September, Wassie Hamilton
• 8.) Beauty and the Beast, December, Janet Wunshell
• 9.) Sabrina Fair, February, Edith Carrington
• 10.) My Three Angels, May, Wassie Hamilton
1961/1962
• 11.) The Drunkard, October, Wassie Hamilton
• 12.) The Giaconda Smile, April, Carl Balsan
• 13.) The Girls in 509, May, Carl Balsan
1962/1963
• 14.) Streets of New York, October, Wassie Hamilton
• 15.) Separate Tables, April, Carl Balsan
• 16.) Curious Savage, May, Carl Balsan
1963/1964
• 17.) Dracula, October, Will Keys
• 18.) Imaginary Invalid, January, Will Keys
• 19.) Someone Waiting, March, Alice Schriener
• 20.) Blithe Spirit, May, Will Keys
1964/1965
• 21.) The Gazebo, November, Will Keys
• 22.) Hedda Gabler, January, Will Keys
• 23.) Breath of Spring, March, Will Keys
• 24.) Man in the Dog Suit, May, Ray Hilton
1965/1966
• 25.) Tender Trap, November, Bob Jones
• 26.) The Fantasticks, January, Howard Scammon
• 27.) See How They Run, March, Ray Hilton
• 28.) Elizabeth the Queen, May, Ray Hilton
1966/1967
• 29.) Tom Jones, September, Ray Hilton
• 30.) A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Foru, January, Robert Weeks
• 31.) The Glass Menagerie, March, Lou Catron
• 32.) Pool's Paradise, May, Ray Hilton
1967/1968
• 33.) Irma La Douce, September, Ray Hilton
• 34.) Witness for the Prosecution, November, Dan Roth
• 35.) Sunday in New York, February, Marion Brown
• 36.) Mary of Scotland, March, Ray Hilton
• 37.) Once Upon a Mattress, May, Dan Roth
1968/1969
• 38.) Stop the World, I Want to Get Off, September, Dan Roth
• 39.) Luv, November, Dan Roth
• 40.) Medea, January, Dan Roth
• 41.) Catch Me If You Can, March, J. Kleeman
• 42.) The Boy Friend, May, Nancy Cole
1969/1970
• 43.) Paint Your Wagon, September, Dan Roth
• 44.) Critic's Choice, November, Gary Battaglia
• 45.) Candida, January, Gary Battaglia
• 46.) The Chalk Garden, March, Cindy Hitchens
• 47.) Baby Want a Kiss, May, Richard Tirrill
• 48.) The Boys in the Band, July, Gary Battaglia
1970/1971
• 49.) Your Own Thing, October, Gary Battaglia
• 50.) Two for the Seesaw, November, Pat Blatt
• 51.) Ladies in Retirement, February, Pat Blatt
• 52.) The Play's the Thing, May, Pat Blatt
1971/1972
• 53.) Lily, the Felon's Daughter, September, Tom Miller
• 54.) The Fourposter, November, Pat Blatt
• 55.) Ghosts, January, Howard Scammon
• 56.) Design for Murder, March, Wassie Hamilton
• 57.) Mary, Mary, May, Pat Blatt
1972/1973
• 58.) Any Wednesday, September, Will Keys
• 59.) Butterflies Are Free, November, Howard Scammon
• 60.) Suddenly Last Summer, January, Sally Darling
• 61.) Wait Until Dark, March, Pat Blatt
• 62.) Arsenic and Old Lace, May, Sam Heatwole
1973/1974
• 63.) The Lady's Not For Burning, November, Sally Darling
• 64.) You Know I Can't Hear You When the Water's Ru, January, Sam Heatwole
• 65.) You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, March, Kate Graverson
• 66.) Delicate Balance, May, Howard Scammon
• 67.) An Evening With Noel and Cole, July, Sally Darling
1974/1975
• 68.) The Last of the Red Hot Lovers, September, Sam Heatwole
• 69.) Outward Bound, November, Howard Scammon
• 70.) Night Must Fall, January, Harvey Credle
• 71.) Absence of a Cello, March, Pat Blatt
• 72.) Another Evening With Noel and Cole, May, Sally Darling
1975/1976
• 73.) Marriage-Go-Round, December, Kate Graverson
• 74.) Thurber Carnival, February, Sally Darling
• 75.) The Gypsy's Curse, April, Bennett Wilson
1976/1977
• 76.) A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Foru, September, Kate Graverson
• 77.) How the Other Half Loves, November, Pat Blatt
• 78.) Sheep On the Runway, January, Sam Heatwole
• 79.) Bus Stop, May, Rogers Hamilton
• 80.) Roar of the Greasepaint, Smell of the Crowd, July, Kate Graverson
1977/1978
• 81.) The Importance of Being Earnest, September, Howard Scammon
• 82.) The Glass Menagerie, November, Sally Darling
• 83.) Barefoot in the Park, January, Sam Heatwole
• 84.) Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, March, Rogers Hamilton
• 85.) Celebration, May, Larry Ketron
• 86.) 6 Rms Riv Vu, June, Jack Poland
• 87.) Noel and Cole - Encore, August, Sally Darling
1978/1979
• 88.) The Little Foxes, September, Tim Jones
• 89.) Once Upon a Mattress, November, Harvey Credle
• 90.) Private Lives, January, Sam Heatwole
• 91.) Ah, Wilderness, March, Sally Darling
• 92.) The Owl and the Pussycat, April, Curry Worsham
• 93.) Riverwind, June, Jim Brittain
• 94.) Same Time, Next Year, August, Sally Darling
1979/1980
• 95.) Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, September, Sam Heatwole
• 96.) Carnival, November, Harvey Credle
• 97.) Sleuth, January, Frank Stevenson
• 98.) You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, March, Bill Taylor
• 99.) Blithe Spirit, April, Kent Thompson
• 100.) By George and Ira, Summer, Sally Darling
• 101.) Invitation to a March, Summer, Frank Stevenson
1980/1981
• 102.) The Mousetrap, September, Dick Overdorf
• 103.) Christmas Fantasia, November, Dann Cunningham
• 104.) All My Sons, January, Kent Thompson
• 105.) Play It Again, Sam, March, Kate Graverson
• 106.) The Voice of the Turtle, May, Jim Brittain
• 107.) The Rose Tatoo, Summer, Sally Darling
1981/1982
• 108.) Chapter Two, September, Frank Stevenson
• 109.) Pippin, November, Kate Graverson
• 110.) On Golden Pond, January, Chris Curran
• 111.) Wait Until Dark, March, Sam Heatwole
• 112.) Romantic Comedy, May, John Hamant
• 113.) One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, Summer, Sally Darling
1982/1983
• 114.) The Skin of Our Teeth, September, Paul Sagan
• 115.) Tintypes, November, Paul Sagan
• 116.) The Gin Game, January, Frank Stevenson
• 117.) Deathtrap, March, Sarah Dixon
• 118.) Absurd Person Singular, May, Kate Graverson
• 119.) Fallen Angels, Summer, Gemma Freeman
1983/1984
• 120.) Harvey, September, Terry Rouark
• 121.) Carousel, November, Mike Sullivan
• 122.) Ladyhouse Blues, January, Pat Blatt
• 123.) The Real Inspector Hound, March, Sarah Dixon
• 124.) Lunch Hour, May, Jane Underhill
• 125.) Two for the Seesaw, Summer, Paul Sagan
1984/1985
• 126.) 1000 Clowns, September, Terry Rouark
• 127.) 1940's Radio Hour, November, Don Cox
• 128.) Talley's Folly, January, Pat Blatt
• 129.) Mass Appeal, March, Art McMaster
• 130.) Breath of Spring, May, Kristi Everly
1985/1986
• 131.) Crimes of the Heart, September, Claudine Carew
• 132.) A Day in Hollywood/A Night in the Ukraine, November, Don Cox
• 133.) The Dining Room, January, Sarah Dixon
• 134.) Ten Little Indians, March, Marvin Sylvest
• 135.) Noel Coward Tonight, May, Howard Scammon
• 136.) 'Night mother, Summer, Sally Darling
1986/1987
• 137.) Sea Marks, September, Dan Smith
• 138.) Best Little Whorehouse in Texas, November, Don Cox
• 139.) Foxfire, January, Kristi Everly
• 140.) The Real Thing, March, Frank Stevenson
• 141.) Painting Churches, May, Anne Morgan
• 142.) Greater Tuna, Summer, Claudine Carew
1987/1988
• 143.) Coupla White Chicks Sitting Around Talking, September, Jane Underhill
• 144.) Stop the World, I Want to Get Off, November, Don Cox
• 145.) The Last Meeting of the Knights of the White , January, Marvin Sylvest
• 146.) The Private Ear/The Public Eye, March, Sarah Dixon
• 147.) The Circle, May, Howard Scammon
• 148.) Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, Summer, Richard Palmer
1988/1989
•  * ) Educating Rita, not produced
• 149.) My Three Angels, November, Jane Underhill
• 150.) Veronica's Room, January, Lori Paschall
• 151.) Biloxi Blues, March, Sarah Dixon
• 152.) The Kingfisher, May, Kristi Everly
• 153.) Moon for the Misbegotten, Summer, Richard Palmer
1989/1990
• 154.) Breakfast With Les and Bess, September, Lori Paschall
• 155.) Some Enchanted Evening, November, Lynn Walker
• 156.) The Nerd, January, Gemma Freeman
• 157.) True West, March, Sarah Dixon
• 158.) Murder by the Book, May, Kim Vernall
1990/1991
• 159.) Steel Magnolias, September, Claudine Carew
• 160.) Bell, Book and Candle, November, Lori Paschall
• 161.) The Cocktail Hour, January, Gemma Freeman
• 162.) The Price, March, Abby Schumann
• 163.) Eleemosynary, May, Bunkie Righter
1991/1992
• 164.) Dial M for Murder, September, Lori Paschall
• 165.) Our Town, November, Howard Scammon
• 166.) Social Security, January, Roman Alis
• 167.) A Walk in the Woods, March, Abby Schumann
• 168.) Nunsense, May, Blanton Bradley
1992/1993
• 169.) Agnes of God, September, Lori Paschall
• 170.) The Lion in Winter, November, Richard Carr
• 171.) Lend Me a Tenor, January, Hugh Hitchens
• 172.) Other People's Money, April, Bunkie Righter
• 173.) The Perfect Murder, June, Debbie Noonan
1993/1994
• 174.) The Road to Mecca, September, Scott Stith
• 175.) Night Watch, November, Lori Paschall
• 176.) Rumors, February, Roman Alis
• 177.) I Never Sang for My Father, April, Bunkie Righter
• 178.) The Fantasticks, June, Bill Suber
1994/1995
• 179.) Amadeus, September, Hugh Hitchens
• 180.) Camelot, November, Bill Suber
• 181.) Dancing at Lughnasa, February, Lori Paschall
• 182.) Out of Order, April, Scott Stith
• 183.) Wait Until Dark, May, Scott Rollins
1995/1996
• 184.) I Ought to be In Pictures, September, Oteka Ball
• 185.) The Boys Next Door, November, Lori Paschall
• 186.) Postmortem, January, Madoline Wallace
• 187.) Shadowlands, March, Les Waldron
• 188.) Later Life, May, Scott Rollins
• 189.) A Private Public Park, June, Jack Zilliox
1996/1997
• 190.) Nunsense II - The Second Coming, September, Ron Milovac
• 191.) The Sisters Rosensweig, November, Beth Fairbanks
• 192.) The Innocents, January, Richard Carr
• 193.) Don't Dress for Dinner, March, Scott Stith
• 194.) Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, May, Scott Rollins
1997/1998
• 195.) I Hate Hamlet, September, Kim Vernall
• 196.) Catch Me If You Can, November, Debbie Noonan
• 197.) Jake's Women, January, Jonathan Manning
• 198.) Two Rooms, March, Les Waldron
• 199.) Barefoot in the Park, May, Naomi Murrow
1998/1999
• 200.) Romantic Comedy, September, Mary Campbell
• 201.) Scotland Road, November, Richard Carr
• 202.) Red Hot and Cole, January, Beth Cheney
• 203.) Picnic, April, Rogers Hamilton
• 204.) The Mousetrap, May, Debbie Noonan
1999/2000
•  * ) Forever Plaid, Summer, Smithfield Little Theater Cast
• 205.) Exit the Body, September, Susan Chast
• 206.) On Golden Pond, November, Richard Carr
• 207.) Dames at Sea, January, Beth Cheney
• 208.) The Cemetary Club, March, Fran Fleming
• 209.) Black Comedy, May, Sarah Carr
2000/2001
•  * ) The Brothers Menaechmus, Summer, Edward Whitace, The New Virginia Company of Comedians
• 210.) Ten Little Indians, September, Lynn Schumann
• 211.) Nuncrackers, November, Helen D'Alfonso
• 212.) Chapter Two, January, Rogers Hamilton
• 213.) Laura, March, Les Waldron
• 214.) You Can't Take It With You, May, Rick Hinson
2001/2002
•  * ) A Delicate Balance, Summer, Richard Palmer, Wedgewood Renaissance
• 215.) Crossing Delancy, September, Mary Campbell
• 216.) Soup du Jour, November, Debbie Noonan
• 217.) An American Daughter, January, Beth Cheney
• 218.) 84, Charing Cross Road, March, Les Waldron
• 219.) 6 Rms Riv Vu, May, Kristi Everly Spivey
2002/2003
• 220.) Picasso at the Lapin Agile, September, Victoria Racimo
• 221.) The Rainmaker, November, Les Waldron
• 222.) The Secret Garden, January, Sarah Carr Howlett
• 223.) Don't Drink the Water, March, Lynn Schumann
• 224.) Play On!, May, Kim Vernall
2003/2004
•  * ) Same Time, Next Year, Summer, Victoria Racimo, Palomino Productions
• 225.) The Good Doctor, September, Beth Wigley
• 226.) The Unexpected Guest, November, Debbie Noonan
• 227.) Cinderella, January, Traci Strom Jackson
• 228.) The Miss Firecracker Contest, March, Kyle
• 229.) Bus Stop, May, Les Waldron
2004/2005
•  * ) Sylvia, Summer, Victoria Racimo, Palomino Productions
• 230.) See How They Run, September, Lynn Schumann & Alan Noblin
• 231.) Over the River and Through the Woods, November, Carole Meyer
• 232.) Man of La Mancha, January, Christopher Robbins
• 233.) Proof, March, Abigail Schumann
• 234.) Deathtrap, May, Les Waldron
2005/2006
• 235.) The Foreigner, September, Lynn Schumann
• 236.) Marvin's Room, November, Bob Burdette
• 237.) A Chorus Line, January, Peter Natale
• 238.) Shirley Valentine, March, Elizabeth Wiley
• 239.) An Act of the Imagination, May, Kate Foskit
2006/2007
• 240.) The Teahouse of the August Moon, September, Rogers Hamilton
• 241.) Sleuth, November, Rob Schrader
• 242.) The Importance of Being Earnest, January, Kathleen Walden
• 243.) Talley's Folly, March, Brandon Lyles
• 244.) A Day in Hollywood/A Night in the Ukraine, May, Don Cox
2007/2008
•  * ) Retreat from Moscow, Summer, Wedgewood Renaissance Productions
• 245.) Baby, September, Rob Schrader
• 246.) Moonlight and Magnolias, November, Brandon Lyles
• 247.) George M!, January, Peter Natale
• 248.) Communicating Doors, March, Rick Hinson
• 249.) Driving Miss Daisy, May, Kyle
2008/2009
• 250.) Pump Boys and Dinettes, September, Dana Margulies
• 251.) Father of the Bride, November, Brandon Lyles
• 252.) The Man Who Came to Dinner, January, Peter Natale
• 253.) On the Verge, March, Les Waldron
• 254.) Barnum, May, Rob Schrader
2009/2010
• 255.) Barefoot in the Park, September, Dale Payne
• 256.) Dial M for Murder, November, Debbie Noonan
• 257.) Arsenic and Old Lace, January, Ed Allen
• 258.) Educating Rita, March, Les Waldron
• 259.) Company, May, Rob Schrader
2010/2011
• 260.) The Dixie Swim Club, September, David Adams
• 261.) It's a Wonderful Life, November, Chris Hull
• 262.) 42nd Street, January, Peter Natale
• 263.) The Lion in Winter, March, Miguel Girona
• 264.) I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change, May, Jeffrey Villines
2011/2012
• 265.) The Producers, November, Peter Natale
• 266.) The Taming of the Shrew, January, Miguel Girona
• 267.) Pride and Prejudice, March, Christina Westenberger
• 268.) Noises Off, April, Kim Vernall
• 269.) Curtains, June, Peter Natale
2012/2013
• 270.) Jesus Christ Superstar, September, Jeff Corriveau
• 271.) The Odd Couple, November, Debbie Noonan
• 272.) I Never Sang For My Father, January, Miguel Girona
• 273.) Steel Magnolias, April, Justin Giroux
• 274.) Chicago, June, Peter Natale
• 275.) Annie, Summer, Peter Natale
2013/2014
• 276.) Moon Over Buffalo, September, Doug Stewart
• 277.) School House Rock, November, Brandon Lyles
• 278.) The Miracle Worker, January, Becky Krantz
• 279.) Rough Crossing, March, AlexMorse
• 280.) Into the Woods, June, Christina Westenberger
• 281.) Peter Pan, the Musical, Summer, Peter Natale
2014/2015
• 282.) Cats, September, Peter Natale
• 283.) Mousetrap, November, Les Waldron
• 284.) Run for Your Wife, January, Peter Natale & Carol Meyer
• 285.) The 39 Steps, March, Abbie Schuman
• 286.) Guys and Dolls, May, Christina Westenberger
• 287.) Oliver!, Summer, Peter Natale
2015/2016
•  * ) James and the Giant Peach, Summer, Center Stage Academy
•  * ) Backwards Broadway, Summer, Williamsburg Players
•  * ) Tarzan, Summer, Center Stage Academy
• 288.) City of Angels, September, Chris Hull
• 289.) Amadeus, November, Catherine Hagner
• 290.) Romantic Comedy, January, Julie King
• 291.) The Front Page, March, Sam Miller
• 292.) Rent, June, Dana Margulies Cauthen
2016/2017
•  * ) History Lessons - a rock cabaret, October, Jeffrey Seyller
•  * ) The Music of Jason Robert Brown, December, Jeffrey Seyller
•  * ) Crazy Ever After - a musical revue, February, Jeffrey Seyller
•  * ) James Cameron - A Conversation with John Rollison
•  * ) Thoroughly Modern Millie, Spring, Center Stage Academy
•  * ) The Hunchback of Notre Dame, Summer, Center Stage Academy
• 293.) Jekyll & Hyde, the Musical, September, Jonathan McCormick
• 294.) The Best Man, November, Neil Hollands
• 295.) Six Degrees of Separation, January, Michael Epson
• 296.) Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, March, Dana Margulies Cauthen
• 297.) On Golden Pond, Spring, Julie King
• 298.) Next To Normal, Summer, Christina Westenberger
2017/2018
•  * ) Leading Ladies, September, Jeffrey Seyller
•  * ) Robert Hodge: Stage and Screen, November
•  * ) A Christmas Carol, December, Brink Miller and Jason Kriner
•  * ) JAMES CAMERON: A CONVERSATION WITH JOHN ROLLISON, March
•  * ) Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, June, Matthew Sanderson
• 299.) You're a Good Man Charlie Brown, September, Valerie Chamness Chin
• 300.) Dandelion Wine, November, Brandon Lyles
• 301.) Lucky Stiff, February, Rosemary Allmann and Marcia DiMattia
• 302.) L.M. MONTGOMERY'S Anne Of Green Gables, April, Julie King
• 303.) Jane Eyre: The Musical, May, Marty Bussert
2018/2019
•  * ) Seussical The Musical, July, Cory Steiger
•  * ) A Christmas Carol, December, Brink Miller and Jason Kriner
•  * ) A CONVERSATION WITH JOHN ROLLISON AND GEORGE WASHINGTON, February
•  * ) Cinderella, June, Dani Doster
• 304.) Shakespeare in Love, September, Justin Giroux
• 305.) Hair, November, Dana Margulies Cauthen
• 306.) Enchanted April, February, Neil Hollands
• 307.) You Can't Take It With You, March, Julie King
• 308.) A Funny Thing Happened On The Way To The Forum, June, Marty Bussert
2019/2020
•  * ) Northanger Abbey - The Musical, October, Marty Bussert
• 309.) ANYONE CAN WHISTLE, September, Marcia DiMattia and Rosemary Allmann
• 310.) CHEAPER BY THE DOZEN, November, Julie King
• 311.) A Christmas Carol, December, Jason Kriner and Brink Miller
• 312.) LAUGHTER ON THE 23RD FLOOR, February, Sam Miller
• 313.) Sister Act, March, Canceled due to COVID
• 314.) The Scarlet Pimpernel, June, Canceled due to COVID
2020/2021
•  * ) Fall into Broadway, November, Jennifer Lent Hamilton
•  * ) No Regular Season 2020 - 2021, Due to COVID
2021/2022
•  * ) 12 Characters in Search of an Audience, May, Julie King
•  * ) Songs from the Golden Age of Broadway, June
•  * ) Broadway Summer, August, Jennifer Lent Hamilton
• 315.) Lilies on the Land, September, Amy Stallings
• 316.) Squabbles, November, Julie King
• 317.) A Christmas Carol, December, Jason Kriner and Brink Miller
• 318.) Mayhem on the Air, January, Neil Hollands
• 319.) Something's Afoot, March, Jacqueline Kilduff and Lisa Velardi
• 320.) Aida, June, Dana Margulies Cauthen
2022/2023
•  * ) WILLY WONKA JR - Gobstopper Cast, June, Cory Steiger
•  * ) WILLY WONKA JR - Nuttariffic Cast, June, Cory Steiger
•  * ) It's Broadway in Times Square, August, Jennifer Lent Hamilton
• 321.) 12 Angry Men, September, Corey Mason
• 322.) ROALD DAHL’S MATILDA: THE MUSICAL, November, Jacqueline Kduff
• 323.) A Christmas Carol, December, Jason Kriner and Brink Miller
2023/2024
• 324.) 84, CHARING CROSS ROAD, January, Julie King
• 325.) AIN'T MISBEHAVIN'
  THE FATS WALLER MUSICAL SHOW, March, Charity Robinson